If you have been told you are being investigated by the Teaching Regulation Agency (TRA), do not reply until you understand the process and have taken advice. What you say in your first response is evidence, and it is read again at every later stage.
A referral is not a finding against you. A case can end with no further action at several points, and a panel can find misconduct proved without recommending a prohibition order. The decisions you make in the first few weeks have a large influence on which way your case goes.
This guide explains who the TRA is, what it can act on, how the process works stage by stage, and what you should do now.
Who the TRA is and who it covers
The TRA is an executive agency of the Department for Education. It investigates serious misconduct by teachers and, on behalf of the Secretary of State, can stop a person from teaching.
Its misconduct powers cover anyone employed or engaged to carry out teaching work in England. That includes schools, sixth form colleges, children’s homes and youth accommodation, and it is not limited to qualified teachers.
The TRA only regulates teaching in England. Teachers in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland are regulated by their own bodies. If you have never taught in a relevant setting in England, the TRA will not investigate you, even if you teach elsewhere.
What the TRA can act on
The TRA can only take a case forward if the allegation, if proved, would amount to one of three things.
- Unacceptable professional conduct: misconduct of a serious nature, falling significantly short of the standard of behaviour expected of a teacher.
- Conduct that may bring the profession into disrepute: conduct that could damage the public’s perception of teachers. Conduct outside school can fall here, but only if it is serious.
- Conviction, at any time, of a relevant offence: a criminal conviction whose nature and seriousness are relevant to teaching, working with children or public confidence in the profession.
The threshold is serious misconduct. Less serious conduct and performance concerns are normally left to your employer.
How the process works, stage by stage
The timescales below come from the TRA’s published procedures. Most are described as “normally”, so individual cases can move faster or slower.
- Referral and initial assessment. A referral usually comes from an employer, often after a school disciplinary process, but can come from the police, another agency or a member of the public. The TRA aims to decide within 3 working days whether the case is within its powers and serious enough to investigate. If it cannot decide within 4 weeks, it tells you a referral has been made.
- Investigation. If the TRA investigates, it writes to you setting out the allegations. You normally have 28 days to send representations and evidence. If new evidence is sent to you later, you have at least 14 days to respond to it.
- Case to answer decision. The TRA then decides whether there is a case to answer. If there is, you have 14 days to say whether you admit the facts and whether you accept they amount to misconduct.
- Meeting or hearing. If you admit everything, you can ask for the case to be decided on the papers at a meeting, using an agreed statement of facts. Otherwise the case goes to a professional conduct panel hearing. The provisional hearing date is normally around 30 weeks after the case to answer decision, and the notice of hearing is sent at least 10 weeks before it. You then have 4 weeks to respond.
- Panel decision. The panel has at least three members, including at least one teacher and one person who has never been a teacher. It decides whether the facts are proved, whether they amount to misconduct, and whether to recommend a prohibition order.
- Secretary of State’s decision. A decision maker acting for the Secretary of State decides whether to make a prohibition order, usually within 3 working days of the panel’s recommendation.
Deciding whether to admit allegations, and whether to ask for a meeting rather than a hearing, are among the most important choices in the process. Get advice before you make either.
Interim prohibition orders
In exceptional cases, the TRA can stop you teaching while the investigation runs. This is an interim prohibition order (IPO), and it can be made without a hearing once the seriousness of the allegation is established.
The timescales are short:
- The TRA tells you within 1 working day of deciding to consider an IPO.
- You have 10 working days to send representations and evidence.
- The TRA decides within a further 5 working days.
There is no right of appeal against an IPO, including to the High Court. A judicial review claim is possible in principle, but it must be brought promptly and within 3 months, and the court will usually expect you to have used the TRA’s review process first. You can apply for a review within the first 6 months, and at 6-monthly intervals after that. Because the window to respond is so short, written representations at this stage need to be right first time.
Convictions, cautions and police matters
A criminal conviction does not automatically lead to a prohibition order. The panel looks at the nature and seriousness of the offence and its relevance to teaching, children and public confidence.
The TRA’s guidance lists offences that are likely to be relevant. They include violence, sexual offences, offences involving children, Class A drugs, fraud and dishonesty, serious theft, and serious driving offences, particularly those involving alcohol or drugs. Minor driving offences are less likely to be relevant.
Cautions matter too. Evidence of a caution carries significant weight, and accepting a caution for one of the listed types of offence is likely to amount to misconduct.
If there is a police investigation or criminal case running at the same time, be careful. What you tell the TRA or your employer can be used in the other proceedings, and the reverse. Take advice on both before you say anything in either.
Possible outcomes
- No further action. The TRA can close the case at the initial assessment, or decide after investigation that there is no case to answer.
- Facts not proved, or not misconduct. If the panel finds in your favour, its findings are only published if you ask for them to be.
- Misconduct proved, no prohibition. The panel can find misconduct but decide a prohibition order is not proportionate. Mitigation, insight and remorse are all relevant here.
- Prohibition order. You cannot teach in England. The order may allow you to apply to have it set aside after a minimum period of at least 2 years. For the most serious cases, the guidance says no review period is likely to be allowed.
Where misconduct is proved, the decision and reasons are published on GOV.UK, normally within 2 weeks.
You can appeal a prohibition order to the High Court within 28 days of the date notice of the order was served on you. That deadline is strict, so take advice as soon as the decision arrives. The High Court’s decision on that appeal is final; there is no further appeal.
What to do now
- Do not reply straight away. Note the deadline in the TRA’s letter, then take advice before you respond.
- Keep everything. Save the referral letter, your school’s disciplinary paperwork, emails and any witness details. Do not delete messages, even ones you think are unhelpful.
- Write down your account while it is fresh, for your adviser only. Do not send it to the TRA or your school.
- Check what your employer has said. The TRA often relies on the school’s investigation, so mistakes or gaps in it matter.
- Gather character evidence. References from colleagues and others who know your work can help, particularly at the sanction stage.
- Think about support. A TRA case is stressful and can take many months. Your GP or an employee assistance programme can help.
Union or solicitor?
If you are a union member, your union may offer representation, and many teachers use it. Some choose independent legal advice instead, or as well, for example where the allegations are serious, there is a parallel police matter, or they want a second view. There is no wrong answer, but make the choice early, before key decisions are taken.
How we can help
Regulatory Defence is a specialist regulatory law firm, regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Jake Herman advises and represents teachers at every stage of a TRA case: the initial response, interim prohibition order representations, admissions and agreed statements of facts, professional conduct panel hearings, and applications to set aside a prohibition order.
We offer a free initial consultation to understand your situation and explain your options. If you then want us to act for you, we will quote both a fixed fee and an hourly rate, and agree the scope of the work and the fee in writing before anything starts. Most clients choose the fixed fee.
Book a free consultation or call 0800 088 4700. You can also read more about our TRA misconduct defence service.